Narcolepsy community shines at FDA public meeting
Representatives from Narcolepsy Network joined hundreds of others from the narcolepsy community at the FDA’s public meeting on narcolepsy drug development on September 24. Approximately 150 people attended the meeting in person at FDA headquarters is Silver Spring, MD, with nearly 700 more attending via an Internet webcast. FDA officials have described the strong response to the narcolepsy meeting as unprecedented.
Patient points of view shared at the public meeting and through a public docket will provide FDA reviewers with helpful insights when conducting benefit-risk assessments for new drugs to treat narcolepsy. Patient responses could also show the FDA that they need new ways to measure the effectiveness of treatments being reviewed.
There were two main areas of discussion at the meeting: â€œdisease symptoms and daily impacts that matter most to patients,â€ and â€œpatients’ perspectives on current approaches to treating narcolepsy.â€ For each topic, a panel of five patients made prepared statements on the topic, followed by a facilitated discussion with the live and online audiences.
Narcolepsy Network member Fran Rosen, 62, traveled from Florida to attend and was a panelist for the first topic, symptoms and impacts that matter most to patients. Like many speakers at the meeting, Rosen identified Excessive Daytime Sleepiness (EDS) as the most problematic symptom for her.
â€œAt a certain point, I had to give up control of my life to narcolepsy. It controls how long I can shop, how long I can read, how long I can work on my computer,â€ Rosen said. â€œCan I go to the party, will I be able to stay up during the meeting, am I able to drive today?â€
Fifteen-year-old Brandon Coonrod said that EDS could cause him â€œto fall asleep anywhere (he is), like sitting quietly in class or at lunch in the cafeteria.â€
Other symptoms that were frequently cited by speakers were cataplexy (the sudden loss of muscle tone brought on by strong emotion), and despite EDS, many people spoke of difficulty sleeping at night. Other patients described the â€œbrain fogâ€ that affects them and told how it creates difficulty in staying focused and completing tasks at school, at work and at home.
Speakers on the second panel, addressing patients’ perspectives on current approaches to treating narcolepsy, described the great benefits of these medications but also their limitations – and for some the great expense.
The mother of a 9 year old who was diagnosed with narcolepsy at 5 said she is worried that her daughter is already taking three medications, one or more of which have never been tested in children. Without these medications, she said her daughter would not be able to go to school. Even so, when she returns home, she is falling over and every day they have to determine which drive is greater – to go to sleep immediately or to eat first.
Many speakers reported having dealt with years, even decades of incorrect diagnoses and being treated with drugs for diseases they didn’t have. Other common themes addressed included general ignorance about narcolepsy, and the difficulties of staying in school, holding a job and even keeping up homemaking and family responsibilities.
Narcolepsy Network member Sharon Link said that sleepiness is no excuse because, â€œemployers won’t put up with missed deadlines or tardiness.â€
Justin Greene of Leesburg, VA told how narcolepsy had interrupted a promising college education and that he had dropped out because he couldn’t keep up the high grades he had always achieved before. â€œI want to be the last of the children to have no choice but to sleep through a bright future,â€ he said.
Nancy Ackerman of Olney, MD, said she has had to reluctantly accept that, â€œmy life will never be as I want it to be.â€
Narcolepsy Network board member Patricia Higgins, a nurse, recounted how, â€œas a result of narcolepsy and cataplexy, I was labeled as a drunk at work, became severely depressed and considered suicide.â€
FDA officials were highly attentive throughout the meeting and through question and answers were clearly learning more about the disease. For instance, speakers helped officials understand that napping is a primary effect of narcolepsy and not just a way of coping with it. However, patients also said that napping boxes out the productive and enjoyable times of their lives. Other discussions with FDA officials focused on the pharmaceutical, behavioral, dietary and lifestyle alternatives that patients try and that their doctors recommend in order to cope with limited medication benefits, progressive aspects of the disease, drug side effects or gradual tolerance to the medications.
â€œAll the panelists and speakers did an outstanding job of representing the many facets of narcolepsy and sharing the challenges that people with narcolepsy face,â€ said Narcolepsy Network Executive Director Eveline Honig, MD, MPH. â€œThis has been such a wonderful opportunity for people with narcolepsy to be heard and to influence the future of narcolepsy treatment. We are very, very pleased with the meeting.â€
The public docket remains open for comments until November 25, 2013. Comment now!
# # #
Date Created: September 25th, 2013
Last Updated: September 25th, 2013